One number, or one for each city
This is the decision Ohio businesses actually get wrong, and it goes wrong in the
same direction every time. A business starts selling into a second metro, buys a
local number there so it looks established, and then has nowhere sensible for that
number to ring. Six months later it is a mailbox nobody empties, which is worse than
never having had it.
A second local number earns its place when one of three things is true: there is a
real office or person in that market, you are running a campaign you want to measure
on its own, or a large customer expects to reach a local desk. Short of that, one
main number with a recorded greeting and extensions behind it serves every market
better, because every caller lands in the same place and is treated the same way.
That structure is set out on auto attendant and
extensions, and the number itself on
business phone numbers.
The part that is the same in all three cities
Worth stating flatly, because location pages tend to imply otherwise. A phone
system that runs over your internet connection is not different in Ohio. It is the
same service, doing the same thing, as it is in Arizona. Nobody makes a regional
edition, and nothing inside it responds to which metro you are in.
What decides whether you are happy is your connection, which is a building
question rather than a state one. Voice needs a steady connection more than a fast
one, so test with a video call at your busiest hour, from the room the phones will
sit in, and judge it on whether it stutters. The comparison against a copper line is
on VoIP vs landline.