Press One for a Menu Nobody Asked For
A phone menu is the only part of a business that speaks to every customer, and it is usually recorded once, in an afternoon, by somebody thinking about how the company ought to sound rather than about the person who is about to ring. That gap is where menus go wrong.
Disclosure: AldoMedia is a paid affiliate of Unitel Voice. If you sign up through a link on this page we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend what we would set up for our own clients, and we say plainly below who should not buy this.
The call that leaves no evidence
It is a Tuesday afternoon and somebody has water coming through a ceiling. They have three numbers from a search. They ring the first one and hear this.
Thank you for calling. Your call is important to us. For sales, press one. For service, press two. For accounts and billing, press three. For all other enquiries, press four.
They press two. The phone that rings is the same phone that would have rung on one, three or four, because there is one phone. The owner answers, the job gets booked, and nothing about that call looks broken.
Two things happened before hello. The caller spent twenty seconds on a decision that changed nothing, and they learnt something about the business that is not true. Neither shows up anywhere you can measure, because the callers who give up around option three do not ring back to explain why.
Menus get written in the wrong direction
Owners write menus from the inside out. You know the shape of your own week, so the options come out as the way the work is divided: sales, service, accounts. The caller arrives from the opposite direction, holding one errand and no knowledge of your internal arrangements.
Nobody has ever rung a plumber because they wanted the service department. They rang because the water will not stop. Your division of labour is not a category the caller owns, so a menu built out of it asks them to guess.
There is a quick test. Write down the last twenty calls and what each person actually wanted, in the words they used rather than the words you would use. Most small businesses find the twenty collapse into two or three piles, one of which is simply people asking whether you do this kind of work at all. Usually the piles and the menu options do not line up, because the options came off the organisation chart and the piles came out of real life.
Every option is a promise in your own voice
An option is a promise. It is recorded in your voice, played to every caller, and it keeps its word only as long as somebody looks after it. Press two for service means there is a service waiting at the other end, and on the day you record it that is perfectly true.
The failure arrives later. Somebody leaves and their extension carries on ringing a desk nobody sits at. A mailbox fills up. A mobile number changes hands. Nothing announces that option three now goes nowhere, and no caller will tell you, because somebody who lands on a dead option does not conclude they were misrouted. They conclude you ignored them.
That is the quiet part. Your website gets looked at and your prices get argued over. The menu was recorded in one afternoon and has been talking to every customer since, and almost nobody listens back to their own. If you have not rung your own number in the past year, you do not know what your business says to strangers. The fuller version of how to build one and keep it honest is on our auto attendant and extensions page.
Menus only ever grow
Adding an option feels like progress. Removing one feels like an admission. So they accumulate. A new service line arrives, so it gets an option. A customer complains about being transferred twice, so that becomes an option too. We have never had an owner ask us how to shorten a menu. We have had plenty ask how to add to one.
Which is why the only useful rule here is a corrective one. If you are choosing between three options and two, take two. If between two and one, take one. If between one option and none, you have just worked out that what you wanted was a greeting.
The correct menu is shorter than the owner wants it to be.
A greeting does most of what a menu is bought for
A greeting is whatever your number says before anything else happens. It differs from a menu in the one respect that matters: it does not ask the caller for anything. No decision, no wrong answer, no twenty seconds spent choosing between departments that may not exist.
Look honestly at what owners want out of a menu. To sound like a real business. To stop people ringing about the same thing. To catch the calls that arrive after five. A greeting covers all three, and it covers them without claiming you have departments.
Sounding like a real business is the one nobody says out loud, and a greeting handles it best. A plain sentence in the owner's own voice sounds like a company that is present. A switchboard sounds like a company you have to get past.
The repeated question is the easy win. If a good share of your calls ask the same thing, the answer belongs where every caller hears it, not behind a number only the correct guessers will press. And after five the menu does nothing at all, because every option leads to the same mailbox. Four doors into one room.
The particular unkindness of a menu in front of one person
If the same person answers every call no matter which key gets pressed, the menu is not merely pointless. It charges the caller for a decision that changes nothing, and plants an expectation the business then has to disappoint.
Follow it through. The caller chose service, so they believe there is a service department. When the call comes back at seven in the evening from the front seat of a van, they do not hear an owner working late for them. They hear a company that had a whole department and still kept them waiting. The menu wrote a cheque every later call has to cover.
Being small is not the weakness the menu is trying to hide. It is usually why the caller chose you. People ring a two-person company on purpose, expecting somebody who knows the job and can decide something. The parts that genuinely help a small team, extensions, voicemail that finds you and routing that knows what time it is, come with a virtual phone system whether or not a caller ever presses a key.
None of this argues against ever recording a menu. A genuinely busy phone, where the wrong person picking up wastes two people's time, gets real value out of two or three well aimed options. The point is narrower. A menu is never free, the whole cost lands on the caller, and the caller is the only party who never gets asked. Ring your own number before you record anything, listen to all of it without skipping, and decide whether the company that just answered is the one you would want to reach.
More from the blog
- What Happens When Someone Types Your Address
- Why Your Business Email Goes to Spam
- What a Website Costs to Run
The full guide to menus, extensions and greetings is on the auto attendant page, and the wider picture is in business VoIP. All posts are on the blog.
Record the greeting first, and the menu only if you need it
Most small businesses get more out of a good greeting, working extensions and an after-hours message than out of anything a caller has to press. If one person answers every call at your business, we will tell you to skip the menu.